Dr. Leafs passion for improving mental health and learning led her to focus her early career in clinical and community settings to get her program to as many people as possible. 9. Lesion mapping of cognitive control and value-based decision making in the prefrontal cortex. So I began my researching of her and found out she has no Christianity, she s morman! What I think is important is to ask whether what Leaf is teaching is steering people away from God or toward God. Leaf. I couldnt shake the feeling so I wondered if anyone else noticed, which is how I stumbled upon your blog. Pray: What a powerful statement that I can say, I am a child of God, chosen before this world was created to do good works for Gods kingdom. Since the early 1980's she has studied and researched the Mind-Brain connection. These topics include: 2. As for your comment that It is clear that whoever came up with this blog is not a true Christian, well again, youre welcome to your opinion. The data will be used to identify needs and priorities, benchmark against various population characteristics, evaluate programs and policies, plan for services and programs, and advocate for resources. We have discussed this at length and I have stated we are not a name it and claim it church, but we do believe healing of all kinds of illness and disease is possible. I just want to know where this is all coming from. 8. I now clearly see why you have written your book. Does this mean we can say, Cancer, be gone, and assume we are healed? Here's exactly how to do it, below: Step 1: Gather. These results strengthen existing research that has established the same relationships. Reduced cervical cancer incidence and mortality in Canada: national data from 1932 to 2006. Not surprising that Dr Leafs teaching that our brain or mind can change our DNA suits them. 1:7). Thank you for your article and your extensive research. Its there in black and white. You are love and although I could never earn it, you pour it out in abundance. KCM Broadcast Notes April 17-21 2023 - The Christian Chain of Command. Her work deserves interrogation and analysis like any other scientific work. Isnt this persistent attack on Ms Leaf a bit pass Mr Pitt? Now Im a bit angry I wasted my money and I will definitely be talking with all the Christians who have suggested her as an authority. It is unnatural not to. They receive messages from other brain cells. We can declare Gods word over our lives. First, understand the triggers and signals for toxic thoughtsthink critically about when, how, and why those thoughts arise. There are many YouTube videos featuring Dr. Thanks for taking the time to write this healthy bit of perspective that is needed with anything thats posted online these days Your brain simply captures what your mind dictates. Jesus entered the world to destroy the works of the enemy. Brisbane, Australia: Pitt Medical Trust, 2014. In fact, we are called to identify with the sufferings of Christ for His glory, and for our refinement. But have we connected the dots laid out in Gods Word, that we can have a healing mindset? Thanks for your comment George. I have been an Ernest Christian since 6th November 1989. Ultimately you can think what you like. All the churches and Christians, myself being one, have swallowed her hook, line, and sinker. Now, we all make innocent mistakes. Please discuss specific symptoms and medical conditions with your doctor. Also, please understand that just because I dont support this kind of theology, does not mean I dont support the idea of the fact that God can heal in His time. How will the world see you Mr Pitt? Its time to call Dr Leafs ministry for what it is. Toxic thoughts can lead to all sorts of different health problems including mental health and even dementia. 6:10-11) and be aware of the lies and deception thats creeping into the church and twisting the Truth. The anterior frontomedian cortex and evaluative judgment: an fMRI study. That can change to amushroom within 21 days. Dr. Leafs passion for improving mental health and learning led her to focus her early career in clinical and community settings to get her program to as many people as possible. You must protect people from the danger of wolves in sheeps clothing as the call of every pastor, and this is Gods directive, not mine. Essentially, there are no formal scientific reviews of her teachings from experts in the fields she reportedly works in, specifically because she doesnt work in those fields. Leaf's research started 38 years ago with her masters thesis and her PhD dissertation work. It is natural to feel compassion for others. Baker Books. . What people do with that truth is up to them entirely, be it intelligent consideration or arrogant dismissal, or anything in between. Colossians 3:2, Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect. Dr. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2012 Sep 4;109(36):14681-6. There are other reviews of Dr Leafs work, some of which are exceptionally perceptive, acerbic, hilarious or a combination. As for your comment that the way this article is written, it appears that you are more interested in vilifying Dr Leaf than presenting legitimate contradictory evidence youre not the first person to raise that, and you wont be the last. Our success lies in our mind. You will also learn how to detox . Hi TM, regarding your comments regarding evidence, the book and every blog Ive written has always been fully referenced. Join Kenneth and Gloria Copeland and Dr. Caroline Leaf on Believer's Voice of Victory, as they talk about five steps to rewire and detox your brain in order to get to the root of why you do what you do. Her husband, Mr Mac Leaf, dismissed my concerns out of hand, which only steeled me to take further action. A number of people from different churches the world over have told me that following Dr Leafs sermons, the pastors have had to provide a type of disclaimer because of Dr Leafs extreme views regarding the management of mental illness. 3. Switch On Your Brain, LLC and the author make no representations or warranties that any individual will achieve a particular result. I also cannot understand why anyone would take the time to write a whole book denouncing and debunking someones work, especially without providing any evidence to back up what youre saying shes saying about science. For a month I tried to work the program which was quite different from the detoxing one. He has given me a sound mind and a spirit filled with his power and love. Thank you so much for your time, and I hope youre staying well! 1 Chronicles 12:32, And of the children of Issachar, which were men that had understanding of the times, to know what Israel ought to do . I have read many of the comments and responses contained herein and it just seems to me that Im watching episodes of and in the red corner are the Pharisees and Sadducees V in the blue corner the Church and the Apostles. My passion is to help people to improve their thinking and mental state so they can have a fulfilled life. And we need to always check what we hear, especially from the pulpit. Rather, join with me in suffering for the gospel, by the power of God. (2 Timothy 1:5-8). In this reductionist view, depression is a chemical imbalance problem of a machinelike brain; therefore, the treatment is to add in the missing chemicals. Please show us the science! I did show you the science. I dont believe shes ever hurt anyone, but rather helped many. I speak life to my immune system. Her fundamental teaching still relies on the idea that our thoughts control our physical and mental health, and toxic thinking causes disease because our thoughts change our DNA and the expression of our genes through epigenetics. Imagine you are kneeling at the feet of God. Dr. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in Communication Pathology specializing in Neuropsychology. [3] Hunter PR, MacDonald AM, Carter RC. Her influence continues to grow. Believers Voice of Victory Video Broadcast for Friday 4/21/2023. If the habit is well established, it can take as long as 3 sets of 21 or 63 days to remove a bad habit completely. I like the reference to Stephen in Acts 6, which I am sure would not have been a good example for Carolyn to use because by her definition, Stephen may have been thinking incorrectly and suffering as a result of it. And in my experience once we stop obsessing about ourselves, our hurts our desires our perceived needs close our ears to the voices that tell us we deserve this and not that and surrender to God, trust in God, make Jesus our portion and accept that the world is not our home depression anxiety etc will reduce significantly or dissappear fully, So after reading all these views and different opinions from different individuals with respectable views all i can say is to any honest reader who is a child of God If you pray and then read scripture says Ill paraphrase if you ask for bread God wont give you a scorpion. This is part of the Jeremiah 17:9 problem. In this devotional based on her bestselling book, Dr. Caroline Leaf combines current scientific research with biblical teaching to help readers understand the power of their thoughts and how to transform their minds. Their mindfulness development and mental health were assessed by the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) scale before and after the program. Inspiration from Dr. Caroline Leaf. Dr Leafs fundamental philosophies are mutually exclusive. As for the haters and the vitriol it comes with the territory. Dr. She is a former award-winning journalist with over 2,000 articles published. Actually, Dr Leaf is trained as a communication pathologist. However I must admit that something from her book did help God give me a huge aha revelation that has plagued me all of my life. Hi Dr. Pitt, We assume that the Emperor must be wearing something because the trusted ministers and noblemen are holding his imaginary train high in the air. In Dr Leafs first case, Dr Leaf herself admitted that the demonstrated improvement of her single patient was just as likely to be related to spontaneous improvement, and not Dr Leafs intervention. Dr Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist, world renowned author, public speaker, and self-titled cognitive neuroscientist. Here is an excellent link to a sermon by Charles Spurgeon called The Carnal Mind Enmity against God. http://www.spurgeon.org/sermons/0020.htm I am very grateful with Dr. Caroline Leaf for the opportunity that she gives mer. I understand now. Im actually rather amused by your pretentious condescension. The Jesus Caroline Leaf and Dr. Strydom is proclaiming is NOT the Jesus of the Bible. Your attacks are unnecessary and unhelpful your brand name is being (or has been) seemingly damaged. She is giving a message of hope is she? Then my kids would close their eyes tight and put their little hands over their ears. I will add that this is not just a matter of opinion, such as topics like pre-destination or the timing on the second coming, etc. Key findings from the 2021 State of the U.S. But that does not mean she enters into the sheep pen by jumping the biblical requirements laid down by Christ and His Apostles. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Books, 2013. God is not trying to teach us through sickness. As Jesus suffered, so anyone who wants to follow Him will also suffer. These statements form the foundation for Dr Leafs major works, and are in print in two best selling books, from which she has used to present countless sermons and seminars around the globe. The hundreds of scientific articles that Ive quoted would counter your position, but you dont seem to be bothered by cognitive dissonance, so I doubt youll be adjusting your narrative. Whether you think Im nice or not is fundamentally irrelevant to the objective truth (or otherwise) of Dr Leafs teaching. Next time you see your physic in Melbourne, let them know why you didnt download Dr Leafs app. They will secretly introduce destructive heresies, even denying the sovereign Lord who bought thembringing swift destruction on themselves. Im going to maintain my stand against Dr Leaf anyway. The theory proposes that everything you say and do is first a physical thought in the physical brain, a thought which you built with your mind. The gift in you discover new life through gifts hidden in your mind. Caroline Leaf may be a qualified "cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in Communication Pathology specializing in Neuropsychology". Watch it now. Really Mr Pitt? This type of prayer increases activity in brain areas associated with social interaction compassion and sensitivity to others. You can grow tens of thousands of dendrites on a single cell. 16 Powerful Affirmations to Declare Boldly during Crisis, 7 Affirmations to Live By in the COVID-19 Crisis, 10 Affirmations for the Parent of a Prodigal Child, 6 Affirmations Your Teen Needs to Hear When Theyre Blowing It, 41 Prayers for Healing Receive Strength & Comfort from God, Need Bedtime Peace? While the scientific research may be excellent, many points from a theological perspective are inaccurate and misleading. God gave us a brain, its appropriate that we actually use it. And no one wants to say anything, because they dont want to look sheepish (or be ostracised). I appreciate your honest assessment, but as their are always critics on all sides, I appreciate you taking the time to dive into scripture. Im not an ordained minister or neuroscientist either and people have dismissed my critique based on my perceived lack of qualifications. This scripture has nothing to do with our mental health. The key issue which EVERYONE ignores isnt Dr Leafs lack of qualifications, but the fact that Dr Leaf CONSISTENTLY embellishes her qualifications. Quantum Physics, no space time dimension. I hope its helpful. Or maybe something like and in the middle of the arena are the Christians and shortly well see the lions making an entrance. I apologise if I missed the context of your previous comments. We are co-creators of our destiny alongside God. A year or so ago I did her detoxification of the toxic thoughts. Lets say your spouse is not as thrilled with you as they were a couple of years ago. debunking dr leaf is here to provide a critical analysis of her teaching, and to present the alternative view. In fact, you cannot be categorized! All rights reserved. I thought what am I going to with myself. Not only were their colors and patterns uncommonly fine, but clothes made of this cloth had a wonderful way of becoming invisible to anyone who was unfit for his office, or who was unusually stupid., If you dont know the story, you can read it here. Routine screening with the much-maligned pap smear has decreased the death rate from cervical cancer in women by as much as 83% [5]. I dont downplay that at all. I agree wholeheartedly. I dont share it though. Reblogged this on my open book and commented: Data collection happens within the app every 21 days for the 20 LMM items and the 8 pro-mindfulness factors as well as a web-based survey (psychdata.com) for user demographics, treatment history, and program experience. Where is your faith? I would have stopped reading at your exclamatory sentence that Quantum physics prove me thoughts can control matter except that there was nothing more to read, since you didnt bother to actually justify your opinion. Your email address will not be published. Texas, USA: Inprov, Inc, 2009. It seems that youve fallen for Dr Leafs humanistic Sci-Fi fantasy version of egocentrism which she claims to be quantum physics. Im a born again Christian and I consulted with the Holy Spirit as she advised you to do. Dr Caroline Leaf has spoken locally several times. Thanks for your comment. I have listened to a couple of her blogs, but they did not resonate with me. Please share your concerns with your pastors, in your church small group, on social media. This view is biblically and scientifically incorrect. [1: p31-32] (Emphasis added). Get on your knees. Would to God ye could bear with me a little in my folly: and . According to Christ, His Apostles and God's Holy Word - Dr Caroline Leaf is a fraud. Bible Study with Dr. Caroline Leaf Posted by Les'a Cole On July 22, 2016 0 Comment Join us for this brain-transforming Bible Study: Thursdays 1-2:30pm. From the NIV, I am reminded of your sincere faith, which first lived in your grandmother Lois and in your mother Eunice and, I am persuaded, now lives in you also. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a brilliant and prolific communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist. More and more, people are realizing that beneath the facade of her numerous Instagram posts, happy snaps, and the allure of popular success, Dr Leafs teachings on science and the Bible dont match up with actual science and good theology. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a cognitive neuroscientist with a PhD in Communication Pathology specializing in Neuropsychology. She is regularly invited to speak at some of the worlds largest churches. Dr.Leaf is not biblical and THIS should be brought to the attention of the body of Christ in the USA and the world. Did she share some statements that could be called into question if not viewed in the right context? The results showed that the students thinking, understanding and knowledge improved across the board. Do you presume that these apply to me? Rather than getting caught up in whether we should go raw or vegan, gluten-free or paleo, Leaf shows readers that every individual is unique, has unique nutritional needs, and has the power . Feel free to share your experiences in the comments section. She does not refers that anxiety is fear. Hold That Thought: Reappraising the work of Dr Caroline Leaf. If you are considering withdrawing from any medication, please do so under the guidance of a professional as withdrawal can be a dangerous process. This statement has been a practice and mindset in our home ever since my kids were old enough to watch TV. Withoutcritique of scientific theories and findings, we would still be living in mud huts as hunter-gatherers. She speaks on diverse topics relating to how the mind controls the brain through optimal thinking, and hence improved brain performance. Throughout this time, Dr. Andi B. Neurocycle Institute Attendee. C) the redemptive power of the resurrection d) our addiction to sin and the fight of Spirit and Flesh E) Sin leads to death(unrepentant heart) F) her blasphemous mouth at comparing the majesty of our Triune God to NewAge magical thinking G)The power we have tin Christ is by His power in us- not power in and of ourselves;as if its some energy field we slingshot over to Africa as if we are little gods H)Fear is real, but those of us in Christ havent been given a spirit of fear PLoS medicine 2010;7(11):e1000361. Quantum physics prove me thoughts can control matter. NOTE: This is NOT a substitute. Reminders are only sent to those who have not yet completed the survey. Ok, well I will look further and read your post again. Leaf is nice. In: GHE_DALY_Global_2000_2011.xls, editor. 2 Timothy 1:7 And in her book Switch on your brain [1], she said on page 33, For now, rest in the assurance that what God has empowered you to do with your mind is more powerful and effective than any medication, any threat, any sickness, or any neurological challenge. ""Is it even Biblical to publicly speak against an anointed leader?, The answer is simple:1. Im also offering sound clinical advice on mental health and illness from a Christian perspective on this blog and also through a book I wrote Kintsukuroi Christians, http://www.kintsukuroichristians.com. Sermon Review: The Jesus Rhythm by Brady Boyd, Source:Chris Rosebrough, Perry Nobles Explanation, Fighting for the Faith,http://www.fightingforthefaith.com/2015/01/perry-nobles-explanation.html, 08/01/2014. One source said she is morman. Dr Leaf even goes so far as to say that our thoughts can control physical matter! Ah well just another lesson learned on this wonderful journey called life. Dr. In my saying it didnt seem like you were being nice, I was referring to the comments made to Laci just a few posts ago wherein you said, my guess is that if you stopped reading one of my blog posts as soon as something challenged your exceedingly shallow world view, then you wont even click on the link. That just didnt seem to be too nice. Thank you, but no apologies are necessary. Who knows you may both find some God ordained middle-ground. Be a servant of Love! Ive just said it loudest and longest. I hope youre out of your cloud of depression, or are almost there, and I wish you all the best for your journey of understanding into psychology. With over 30 years in research and studies, she delves into Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess with these five simple steps to help reduce our anxieties, stress and toxic thinking. Withoutcritique of scientific theories and findings, we would still be living in mud huts as hunter-gatherers. Hebrew 4:12 For the word of God is living and active. Giving her the benefit of the doubt about her teaching is very gracious, but irrespective, intentionally pretending to be a cognitive neuroscientist, deliberately exaggerating her own qualifications, should have disqualified her a long time ago. Switch On Your Brain Every Day: 365 Readings for Peak Happiness, Thinking, and Health : Leaf, Caroline: Amazon.ca: Livres She was one of the first in her field to study how the brain can change (neuroplasticity) with directed mind input. God has given us everything, and we have to step into our perfect selves to succeed in this area. You mention Kenneth Copeland, Joyce Meyer, Hillsong and I have seen Stephen Furtick also interviewed her. [9] Zysset S, Huber O, Ferstl E, von Cramon DY. Biblical Meditations. Those of us who are just beginning to research the mind/brain psychology really need to continue our studies to truly understand what is going on. Every time we learn new information, we grow more dendrites. 10 Introduction 1. Theyre welcome to agree or disagree, and theyre free to say what they want. Did she share thought provoking content? I take your point that the truth of a persons message isnt dependent on their qualifications. Leaf, who should know better, is playing fast and loose with research and information. The others (2 25%) come from exposure to chemicals in food, etc. This suggests a topic called Mind (or Religious) Science, basically suggesting that man can control his own destiny. This is DECEPTION! She is a neuroscientist talking about the power of the brain and mind. Ive recently been going through one of the deepest, longest periods of depression Ive had for the last few years, and its just as unpleasant as the last time. At the same time, you do seem to support it, and proclaimed it Sunday by reiterating that we had this speaker at the church. So essentially, their perspective is that the brain creates what you are doing and what you are thinking. Leaf trained educators and therapists on classroom-based intervention for learning and mental health management that impacted the lives of thousands of students and teachers. Thats certainly a lot more than most, and Im always grateful for those that do. She used this scripture a number of times on her social media feeds, including on the 4/2/2015, The more you believe in your own ability to succeed, the more likely it is that you will. She also quoted James 1:15 interpreting it as our toxic thinking leads us to death. Im hoping Janet takes a look at it and is a Berean. I am also of course, interested in any correction you have to offer me. #How to Create a Metacog #Metacog #Neurocycle #Dr Leaf #neuroplasticityPlease, download the printable fromhttps://tinyurl.com/nj97xujp BMC public health 2012;12:992. It would be much easier just to give my personal opinion. When we were born, most of us came out of the womb, and into this world, head first. To summarise, Dr Leaf has directly called her own beliefs and teaching biblically and scientifically incorrect, and not noticed. As can be seen in the above animation, there are four main parts to a brain cell: The dendrites branch out from the cell body. For more information on Dr. They are seeking truth. That Dr Leaf also regularly misquotes her sources and relies on unpublished opinion from pseudoscientists and new-age practitioners also brings her reputation as an expert scientist into disrepute. You think, and then you do, which cycles back to the original thought, changing it, and the thoughts connected to it, in a dynamic interrelationship. If you want to discuss in detail I suggest setting up a meeting. For example, Dr Leaf quoted a source on genetics that was over thirty years old, from a time when genetic studies were still in the dark ages. 1:7). Her own fundamental philosophies contradict each other. No better time to introduce these strategies than now. Each scripture offered here has been turned into a declaration and a prayer. We will all be judged for what we teach or allow to be taught in our sphere of influence about the things of God, so never mind my email. Her main evidence comes from a poster presentation at a 1993 psychotronics conference titled, Local and nonlocal effects of coherent heart frequencies on conformational changes of DNA [11]. and biblical insight, Dr. Caroline Leaf empowers readers to take control of their thoughts in order to take control of their lives. Though in terms of critique from other scientists or medical doctors in neuroscience, cognitive neuroscience, or mental health, there might be a few now, but nothing formal. Many people ask why an alternative view is needed.Why criticise Dr Leaf? Hey, if you want to confuse cognitive biases, magical thinking and ignorance for the leading of the Holy Spirit then go for it.